Wednesday, September 16, 2009

BOOKS vs E-books and the unbook


Cory Doctorow's article on Writing in the Age of Distraction really made me think about my own styles in writing. I can be very easily distracted when I am doing something that I don't want to be doing. I liked the idea of setting apart 20 minutes a day to write. It can be applied to almost anything. I immediately thought of reading. I notice that I don't mind reading assignments as much when I take them a little bit at a time, especially when the reading is boring. I just have to get into the routine of opening that book. I get it done little by little and it doesn't seem to be as much of a chore. I'm not so sure about stopping in the middle of a sentence when writing. If I have something really good, I would hate to stop since I would most likely forget. I would rather finish my thoughts. Instant messengers really are a distraction. I admit that when I sit down and am serious about getting my work done, I sign it off. I guess I have a few things I agree with and a few things in which I disagree. Everyone has their own style that works for them, but for me I like to relax and play music when I do homework. It helps me to relax.

Steven Johnson mentions in How the E-Book Will Change the Way We Read and Write that "book's migration to the digital realm would....make it easier for us to buy books, but at the same time make it easier to stop reading them." I completely agree with this. Although I don't mind reading news or magazine articles online, since it takes all of 5-15 minutes to read them and its easier to access, I prefer taking a book somewhere I can get cozy to read it. Looking at a computer screen for too long starts to hurt my eyes. He said that books can't compete with internet technologies anymore. I look at it the other way around. Neither can compete with each other. They are two different classes that can't be judged on the same terms. Both have good qualities and bad qualities. I just really like books. I like the idea of a free sample chapter though. It might help me sift through the books I might like.

How is the "unbook" really going to let me help an author write a book? All I see happening from what was said in On the changing roles of authors and readers is that the author would change his or her vision of how a book plays out just so that it will be more accepted in the reading community. I think that would take away from the author's creativity in writing and the passion out of the reader.

3 comments:

  1. Many, myself included, have a strong physical connection to books, to the materiality and to the ritual of 'curling up with a book.' For those reasons (among others), I will continue to buy books for my own use, but I can see more practical purposes for ebooks in educational settings.

    Regarding future interactions between authors and readers, though, peer review groups are a major aspect in creative writing (and some first-year writing) courses. Given the kinds of success apparent there, why not extend the same idea online?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I still have to disagree with the practicality of E-books in the educational setting. Although they are much lighter in comparison to actual books, you can not sell them back. With the costs of books skyrocketing, it just doesn't seem that practical for the college student, maybe for teachers though.

    I do agree that it would be beneficial to have peer review groups online for writing courses, but not for novels. I maintain that it would take away the author's creativity. Readers would not be as passionate about books, because the author would change sections. Books would be way to sujective.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What if these college e-books themselves were rentals? Students could pay an initial cost to keep an e-book in their possession for the duration of a semester, a year or a couple years. On top of that, there could be a set price on textbooks and course readings, all of which would be downloaded to the e-book for that semester. The e-book would get a memory wipe at the conclusion of each semester.

    ReplyDelete