Wednesday, September 30, 2009

Plagiarism

Defining and Avoiding Plagiarism: The WPA Statement on Best Practices states that "In an instructional setting, plagiarism occurs when a writer deliberately uses someone else’s language, ideas, or other original (not common-knowledge) material without acknowledg ing its source."

For years I have been taught that Plagiarism is wrong and that I have to all of my references or either fail or be kicked out of school. When having to cite references I always thought, "How can I be sure that the ideas that I think that I came up on my own are really my ideas and not the ideas of another person's work?" Any idea that I think that I can claim as original is really something that has been taught to me by either my parents, my friends, in a classroom, by books, television, and/or online. Can any errant thought really by my own, or does someone already have a claim on it? Should we someday have to cite every sentence that we speak or write? These are my own thoughts on plagiarism.

But then I look at the article, The Ecstasy of Influence: A Plagiarism, by Jonathan Lethem. He quotes John Donne saying, "All mankind is of one author, and is one volume; when one man dies, one chapter is not torn out of the book, but translated into a better language; and every chapter must be so translated. . . ." This perfectly parallels what I had said about originality.

I really enjoyed when Lethem said, "Finding one's voice isn't just an emptying and purifying oneself of the words of others but an adopting and embracing of filiations, communities, and discourses. Inspiration could be called inhaling the memory of an act never experienced." When it comes to plagiarism and pirating, I like what Jefferson wrote, “He who receives an idea from me, receives instruction himself without lessening mine; as he who lights his taper at mine, receives light without darkening me.”

The article Scientist explain why they plagiarize, by Dan Vergano, brings up an excellent point. He mentioned that doctors and researchers make decisions about treatments and experiments on published scientific works. If inaccurate data is passed around through plagiarism, doctors and researchers could take this incorrect information and incorporate it into their scientific studies. The outcome could be potentially fatal for their patients.

Michael Leddy also brought up a good point in his blog post, What Plagiarism Looks Like. He said, "Plagiarism seems to be governed by a sliding scale, with consequences lessening as the wrongdoer's status rises." As true as this statement is, it is as equally wrong. No one should be an exception to the law, no matter what their status.

Monday, September 28, 2009

Stranger Than Fiction Observation

Not many people today like to read books anymore, let alone do they personally know an actual writer. That being said, how can we know if writers are being precisely characterized on film? Stranger Than Fiction, a movie directed by Marc Forster, has many good examples of what I think are accurate and inaccurate portrayals of writers and writing. Certain themes that I found accurate in the film were writing styles, paralleling the author's life, daydreaming, personification, and the authors conscience. Aspects that I found inaccurate were stereotypical views and the reversal of roles between the author and the character.

The movie accurately portrays that every author has their own distinct style when it comes to writing. The scene where Harold Crick was seeking advice from the literary expert, Jules Hilbert, about the voice that he was hearing is a great example. Only when Harold remembered that the voice had begun with "little did he know," did Jules say that he could help him. Writers tend to find an approach to writing that works best for them and stick with that style.

From my limited experience with reading novels and learning a little about the authors who wrote them, I have found that writers tend to use places, names, and people that they are familiar with and incorporate them into their stories. Karen ate alone, slept alone, and even worked alone, which was the same for Harold Crick. Their apartments were orderly and even when the assistant came into her life and changed it, Harold met Ana Pascal. She wrote what she knew and it ended up being that her main character's life paralleled her own.

I can not generalize to all writers, but I know that when I write, or read, I tend to put myself in the place of the characters. I will either imagine what I want to happen or I will go to different places to gain inspiration for what I want to happen. It helps to bring the situation to life. Karen Eiffel seemed crazy to her assistant when she was sitting out in the rain or going to the hospital looking for dying people, but it helped her research her characters and create her story.

At the beginning of the movie, Harold's watch goes crazy. It tries to warn him and then it ends up saving him. Obviously a watch wouldn't, or couldn't, do that. It's an accurate portrayal in that the author tied the start of the craziness in his life in with the reason why he dies. Personification makes things interesting and that is why writers use this type of literary metaphor. If writers didn't personify objects, then Harold might have died either because the watch set him off schedule which resulted in his "imminent death", or he would have lived because he would have missed that bus that ends up hitting him.

It isn't realistic to meet the characters from your books that you are about to kill off, in real life anyway, but if it were to happen I'm sure things would turn out the way they did in Stranger Than Fiction. When Karen meets her character who she is planning to kill, she has second thoughts. She becomes a nervous wreck and tries to rewrite the story before he dies. She changed the book because she realized she just couldn't do it. She couldn't kill her character if she thought that it would have actual consequences. She develops a conscience. Karen says "It's a book about a guy who doesn't know he’s going to die, not about the guy who knows he’s going to die and dies willingly." She thinks that is the kind of guy that she should keep alive. If this happened to me, I know that I couldn't live with myself if I were to have killed Harold Crick.

The portrayal of Karen Eiffel as a writer, I thought, was very inaccurate. It is very stereotypical to think that all writers are chain smokers, that they live alone, that their lives are bland, or even that they will eventually do something a little bit crazy. If we were all being honest, I'm sure we would admit that we all sometimes go crazy about certain things.

The author in the movie, Karen Eiffel, refuses to work with the assistant who was hired to help her finish her novel. She thinks that the assistant will not be able to help her because she is only an assistant, not a writer. People are always classifying people into groups and stereotyping them. Karen Eiffel had no idea about the assistants background or whether she had any experience with writing, or the writing process. Although this accurately portrays the world in which we write, it is not an accurate description for all writers. The assistant may have been a writer, but found better work as an assistant who helps writers with completing their books and overcoming writers block.

The last aspect that I think is the most inaccurate view of writing is that the story is dependent on the character and what he does instead of the character depending on the author and what she writes. The character would not react to, or be able to hear the narrator, but if they could hear the narration, the character's decisions would be affected and then that would become part of the authors story.

Although Stranger Than Fiction definitely shows a skewed view of writing, the stereotypes are what made the movie the comedy it is. Movies will never be genuine depictions of how writer's are. But it cracks me up every time I see when Harold calls Karen at the exact moment she finishes her sentence and makes it permanent with the period, and freaks her out.

Thursday, September 24, 2009

Observation Notes

When author is talking to assistant she thinks that the assistant can't help her since she is only an assistant, when in reality she has helped many authors finish their novels on time.

"Little did he know" Each author has their own style of writing that people associate with them. When harold was speaking with with literary expert, the expert recognized the phrase.

She sits out in the rain to come up with scenarios. (i.e. jumping off a cliff, car running of the bridge.)

nurse wanted to know if she was suffering from something. She said "writers block"

Harold Crick's life is being narrated by an author who had never met him before, which would not happen in actuality. The character would not react to narrator, but if they did it would become part of the authors story. It seems like the author is dependent on the character instead of the character depending on the author.

The story seems dependent on what Harold does instead of what the character writes. Only certain things he does are narrated.

The author writes that Harold was fighting to get a hold of her, but when he does she freaks out.

An interesting end to the movie would be if he only would have died if his clock hadn't reset.

The author has a conscience, when she meets the character she is about to kill in a book in real life, she has second thoughts.

At the end, the author goes from wanting to kill Harold to not wanting to. Harold is scared of dying, but at the end he is resolved to following through with her ending.

She becomes a nervous wreck when she tries to rewrite the story before he dies.

Shard of glass from watch saves his life.
"A wrist watch saved Harold Crick!"

She changed the book because she realized she couldn't do it. It's a book about a guy who doesn't know hes going to die, not about the guy who knows hes going to die and dies willingly. She thinks that is the kind of guy you should keep alive.

AWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW!!!

Monday, September 21, 2009

Personal Writing History

    Writing has never been my favorite thing to do. I often struggle with getting the ideas from inside my head onto paper. It takes hours of contemplating different questions and scenarios before I come up with something that I am truly inspired to write about. The writing process I follow has consistently evolved over the years.

    I can remember back to when I was first starting to write. I remember learning how to write in print and cursive in the first grade. I really strived to be a good writer. I always seemed to be comparing how I wrote with other students hand-writing. I was neither the best or worst writer in the class. But because I was so competitive, I made myself practice. My first experience with computers was in the first grade as well. In Mrs. Voto’s class we learned to type and use different computer programs. I know this was to my benefit that I learned how to use computer’s early in my life. These skills are harder to learn and master later in life.
   
I went to a Catholic school, Holy Redeemer, through fifth grade. Every Wednesday we were required to attend mass as part of the religious education program. After mass, we were required to write about the theme of the mass. I had Attention Deficit Disorder as a child and could never sit still long enough to pay attention to what was going on. This made it extremely hard for me to think of anything to write, anything I could hand in to the teacher. As with any beginner, honestly, I was a terrible writer.

    My dad has been the guiding influence in my life of academics. Growing up in his household has also helped me move past most of my insecurities and grow as a writer. He taught me to motivate myself in my learning endeavors. He refused to help me on homework, but he had one piece advise that has stuck with me when it comes to writing. He would tell my to look up any words that I didn’t know or that I didn’t know how to spell. He never gave in. I realize now that he did this so that when I got a grade I would know that I deserved what I had worked for. I’ve learned that life is not easy and things are not handed to us. We have to work hard for the things that we want. I’m not a perfect writer, but I’m a better writer today for what he taught me.

    High school English continued to further me as a writer. As well as learning better grammar, I learned how to write better narratives and essays. I became more and more familiar with the MLA style of writing and the research process in general. They prepared me for writing in college and the classes that I am in right now. I would have been lost without Mr. Piggar's Senior Research Skills class at Davison High School.
 
   Today, I write in a way that incorporates my past experiences, but also in a way that demonstrates my personality. I am a very free-spirited writer. I don’t follow the normal writing procedure when I sit down and write. I always plan my papers mentally before I write it down, instead of brainstorming, and I don’t always write my introductions first. I may even be obsessive-compulsive when it comes to my writing atmosphere. My writing style has changed a lot over the years, but I have a system that works for me.

    Although I do not use the classical brainstorm techniques, planning is an extremely important concept for my writing process. I am constantly planning, whether it is for writing or not. I like to get comfortable before I write and think of what I’m trying to accomplish with my writing and how I want to organize my thoughts. Even though the plans may change, I like to know where I am going, and what I need to do to get there. Figuring out where I am going definitely helps make the writing process easier for me. I tend to have a hard time expressing myself through words, so avoiding writing them down until I have thought about what I want to say and how to say it helps me to not get caught up in the insecure moments that make writing hard for me.

    I usually have a hard time with starting introductions. The way the introduction is worded can limit what I can talk about in the body of a paper. Writing it last, I can incorporate all of my ideas into my thesis. Once I have an idea of where my ideas are taking me, I usually know what I want to say in my introduction.

   I have noticed that I have to have certain conditions when I write. I work better when the room that I am working in is clean. I can focus better on the task at hand when I know that my mind won't wander to other things that I need to get done. My desk tends to stay extremely tidy, because I have a place for everything. I have grown up with the concept of leaving things they way I found them. Having a clean work space helps me to write more clearly.

    My personality and experiences are constantly molding and changing my writing. I've learned things along the way that have helped me when I write. I have come to expect that my writing will continue to change. I may never be a perfect writer, but at least I know what works for me.



Wednesday, September 16, 2009

BOOKS vs E-books and the unbook


Cory Doctorow's article on Writing in the Age of Distraction really made me think about my own styles in writing. I can be very easily distracted when I am doing something that I don't want to be doing. I liked the idea of setting apart 20 minutes a day to write. It can be applied to almost anything. I immediately thought of reading. I notice that I don't mind reading assignments as much when I take them a little bit at a time, especially when the reading is boring. I just have to get into the routine of opening that book. I get it done little by little and it doesn't seem to be as much of a chore. I'm not so sure about stopping in the middle of a sentence when writing. If I have something really good, I would hate to stop since I would most likely forget. I would rather finish my thoughts. Instant messengers really are a distraction. I admit that when I sit down and am serious about getting my work done, I sign it off. I guess I have a few things I agree with and a few things in which I disagree. Everyone has their own style that works for them, but for me I like to relax and play music when I do homework. It helps me to relax.

Steven Johnson mentions in How the E-Book Will Change the Way We Read and Write that "book's migration to the digital realm would....make it easier for us to buy books, but at the same time make it easier to stop reading them." I completely agree with this. Although I don't mind reading news or magazine articles online, since it takes all of 5-15 minutes to read them and its easier to access, I prefer taking a book somewhere I can get cozy to read it. Looking at a computer screen for too long starts to hurt my eyes. He said that books can't compete with internet technologies anymore. I look at it the other way around. Neither can compete with each other. They are two different classes that can't be judged on the same terms. Both have good qualities and bad qualities. I just really like books. I like the idea of a free sample chapter though. It might help me sift through the books I might like.

How is the "unbook" really going to let me help an author write a book? All I see happening from what was said in On the changing roles of authors and readers is that the author would change his or her vision of how a book plays out just so that it will be more accepted in the reading community. I think that would take away from the author's creativity in writing and the passion out of the reader.

Tuesday, September 15, 2009

Random, but fun!

Since we just debated about this in class today, I thought it would be funny to share a story from an e-mail I just got like 10 minutes ago on Facebook.

My best friend, Stacey, wrote me:
"YES! I am looking forward to it! i wanted to go to the DNR tomorrow too so we can do it all together :) lol just give me a call when you're ready or just come on over :)"

My responce:
"DNR?? What does Do Not Resuscitate have to do w/ what we are going to do tomorrow?? LOL What did you mean by DNR???"

When I realized what she meant:
"OOOOOOOH!! Never mind!! Duuuh!!"

Anyways, I just wanted to share. I hope this made you all smile!!

Monday, September 14, 2009

Writing

I can honestly say that I used to hate having to write. I absolutely loathe writing papers and essays. I dislike the "writing process" with a passion. It's too formal and doesn't have any personality. Being forced to write using brainstorming, rough drafts, and revisions has put a stigma on writing for me. It simply took all the joy out of it. Facebook, Myspace, and Twitter type devices have definitely motivated me to write more and because of them I have found that I can enjoy writing again. I had never really thought about updating my Facebook as writing.

I can completely agree with Anne Trubek when she said in We Are All Writers Now, that "Students saw writing as alien and intimidating--a source of anxiety." I took an English class where I had to write a narrative about "how I became the writer I am today." The professor handed back our papers saying that our writing was not what he had expected and that we had to re-write them. When he finally graded my paper (in which I got a D) he told me that I didn't know how to write a narrative. I compared my writing to others in the class and they thought that my writing was comparable to theirs (they had received above average grades) and that I was unfairly graded. He ended up asking me to drop the class because he knew I wouldn't do well. This definitely caused me a lot of anxiety and writing has been even more intimidating since.

Although the statement by "You want to tell them what you're going to tell them, tell them, then tell them what you've told them." is completely true, it is exactly the reason why I hate writing papers. Introductions and conclusions make informative essays very redundant.

In Words For Prints Vs Words For Web, gaming came up a bunch. I know that the author had been working for a gaming magazine, but I just didn't see why he actually brought up gaming topics. It was way over my head. But Even though I agree that online writing has it's advantages, I still prefer to read a book instead of a PDF on the computer. My complaint is about being stuck sitting in front of the computer monitor, whereas with a book you can take it anywhere. It is just more comfortable that way. I get a lot more done when I am comfortable. It would be interesting, if some day, an author of a book included a complimentary online version so that looking into references could be much easier. I would still prefer the hard-copy though.

Friday, September 11, 2009

Blogging and Twitter

I really enjoyed the readings for today's class. I was scared of this class when I signed up for it thinking that I would be writing a million papers on books that I would hate, but I think I will get along very well with this class!

McSweeny's Internet-age Writing syllabus was hilarious! I loved that the focus was on writing without using nouns, verbs, and conjunctions. If this class was offered, I would take it in a heart beat. My favorite part was when he was coming up with acronym's. It was interesting to me because he wants us to be expressive with our use of them, but anyone else who would look at them would be like "WTF?"

I have never been a big fan of blogging, but Blogging essential for a good career made me question my reasoning. I've always thought that what I had to say was not very interesting. I am the type who wants to say something interesting and fun, but then I struggle over my words. Once I get something down on paper (or should I say world wide web?) I end up deleting it because I start feeling self conscious about how others will react to it. After reading this article I have a new perspective on blogging. Now that I have a focus that pertains to everyone in the class I am more open to writing. It actually gives me the motivation to maybe create a blog about nursing school and my future career!

My favorite part of on blogging and becoming a better writer was when the author wrote "becoming good at anything worth becoming good at takes a lot of time." That can be said about all walks of life. I'm adding that to my quote book!

I signed up for twitter this summer and a week later I was already sick of it. I honestly had no understanding on how it worked, so I just gave up on it. Now that I have learned about how to use it, I'm not so sure. But after reading How the Other Half Writes: In Defense of Twitter I have learned that anything new is always going to be feared. There is no difference between writing in a book, using a pen, or Twitter. People are just expressing themselves.

Although I disagree with Maria Puente when she said that blogs are so 2004, I absolutely loved her Twitter update at the end, "@WiredReader: Kill yr blog. 2004 over. Google won't find you. Too much cruft from HuffPo, NYT. Commenters are tards. C u on Facebook?" I think that blogging still can be very beneficial! Here's the article!

In There's an art to writing on Facebook or Twitter -- really, Maria Puente quoted someone who made an excellent point to promote Twitter and blogging. Adam Ostrow said, "Personality is really what drives people to (follow) you, especially on Twitter." So I wish people would stop complaining about what people decide to write on Facebook and Twitter. Who cares if someone isn't witty and clever all the time? That's what makes them who they are...

Wednesday, September 9, 2009

New to blogger

Yay! I'm blogging...

:)

Looking forward to posting more soon!